Congratulations to everyone, amazing work!
@kortniechan The ARK Video contest is by design pretty open and freeform, intended to show off the most creative content entered outside of straight builds. While I really do understand what you are saying, I have to say that I think that the winning entry falls pretty firmly into the "creative" category. I hope you don't take any offense to that point of view.
Now as far as the contest rules are concerned, I don't think they need a huge overhaul. I don't enter every week, and when I do I have had a pretty mixed bag of successes and not placing. I have never felt that the contest was skewed in any way, though obviously the more you enter the more chances you have to win. (as long as you put some of yourself into each entry). Some folks do try and "farm" the contest, I suppose that's to be expected when a generous cash prize is involved, but usually those attempts are fairly obvious to spot and I don't think are a significant problem.
Nor do I have a problem with how ties are handled, especially if circumstances have postponed the contest by a week. WC doesn't have to shell out extra prizes in that situation, but they often do.
I do feel that a restriction to 1 video per category wouldn't be a bad thing, but if a person wants to (and has the entries to do so) they should be able to freely enter as many DIFFERENT contests as they like. This would avoid folks flooding a particular contest with their backlog of videos simply for the exposure. I fully understand the temptation, but it is really something that in my opinion should be avoided. That being said, I believe that the current emphasis in all contest categories on creativity trumping sheer size or fancy mods allows these contests to function as intended. I rely heavily on mods, and have zero issue if a small vanilla build wins by being more clever (or beautiful) than mine. By the same token, sometimes creative use of or blending of mods can be an art form all in itself.
I also feel it "might" not be out of line to stipulate that a particular video or piece of art should only be entered into ANY of the contests only once, but that would require someone to keep accurate record of all of the entries, and that might be a bit problematic. Winning entries at the very least should be restricted from resubmission, but I don't think we've ever had a problem with that before anyway. More often than not something gets entered two weeks in a row because someone wasn't sure if they got their entry submitted in time.
I know that we do have a section of the forums devoted to featured art/videos, but a permanent section devoted to contest winning entries (organized by contest and date) might be a nice touch. Something that new players can find and browse through easily. Or perhaps even just an easy to find archive with all of the Crunches grouped together in an organized fashion might be easier.
And finally, I don't think anyone would object if more contests or "places" (1st, 2nd, 3rd) were introduced... but in saying this I also realize that doing so might be more complicated that it first appears... and in no way do I want to give the impression that these contests in their current form are not appreciated or fall short in any way. We all know you don't have to do this, and that it doesn't "just happen" every week. All of your hard work in judging and organizing the Crunch is greatly appreciated by the community. That goes for the people participating as well as those that simply love viewing the entries.